The crux of the telecom companies’ defence rested on the assertion that their relationship with distributors was that of principal to principal, not principal to agent as argued by the Income Tax department
In a recent landmark judgement, the Supreme Court has granted telecom companies relief from the obligation to deduct tax on the sale of discounted pre-paid SIM cards and recharge vouchers to their distributors. This ruling, which concerns Section 194H of the Income Tax Act, marks a significant decision in favour of telecom giants such as Vodafone Idea and Bharti Airtel.
Understanding the Verdict
Section 194H of the Income Tax Act pertains to Tax Deduction at Source (TDS) on payments made as commission or brokerage. The Supreme Court, however, clarified that this section does not apply to the transactions involving telecom companies and their distributors.
Effectively, this means that telecom firms are no longer required to deduct TDS for providing pre-paid SIM cards to distributors at rates below the market price. The court’s ruling overturns previous contradictory judgments by both the Calcutta High Court and the Delhi High Court.
Background of the Case
The Supreme Court addressed this issue amidst a batch of 40 appeals, all revolving around the question of whether TDS should be applicable to discounts offered to pre-paid distributors on the sale of SIM cards and recharge vouchers.
Telecom companies argued convincingly that the reduced sale prices given to distributors should be considered as discounts rather than commissions. Hence, they contended that TDS deductions were not warranted in these cases.
On the other hand, the Income Tax department argued for the classification of these discounts as commissions, justifying the need for TDS deductions. Additionally, they characterized the relationship between telecom companies and distributors as that of principal and agent.
The Court’s Rationale
The crux of the telecom companies’ defence rested on the assertion that their relationship with distributors was that of principal to principal, not principal to agent as argued by the Income Tax department. This argument found favour with the Supreme Court, leading to its ruling in favour of the telecom firms.
Impact on Telecom Industry
This ruling marks a significant victory for telecom giants such as Vodafone Idea and Bharti Airtel. It provides them with financial relief by exempting them from the burden of deducting TDS on discounted sales to distributors.
In conclusion, the Supreme Court’s ruling brings clarity and relief to the telecom industry, establishing a precedent that discounts on sales to distributors should not be subject to TDS under Section 194H of the Income Tax Act. This decision is poised to have a positive impact on the operations and finances of telecom companies across the nation.
To Access the Notification of I-T Dept on Implementation of e-Verification Scheme 2021 CLICK HERE
Also Read
Capital Gain Deductions can be Claimed Without CGAS Deposits: ITAT Delhi
Way to Verifying ITR after the Deadline as Stipulated under Income Tax Act 1961