Income tax officials may analyze an individual’s declared expenses in comparison to their bank records, which include credit/debit card transactions and cash withdrawals.
The middle class has been facing increasing scrutiny regarding income tax compliance, with discussions intensifying before the Union Budget 2025. A recent social media post has sparked widespread concern over an Income Tax Department notice that appears to demand extensive details about taxpayers’ personal expenditures. This request for information has raised questions about the government’s approach and left many frustrated.
Can the Income Tax Department Ask for Such Personal Expense Details?
Tax experts explain that income tax officials may analyze an individual’s declared expenses in comparison to their bank records, which include credit/debit card transactions and cash withdrawals. The objective is to ensure compliance with tax laws and detect any undisclosed income. By comparing spending patterns with documented financial records, authorities aim to identify inconsistencies.
Niyati Shah, Vertical Head – Personal Tax at 1 Finance, highlights that the recent scrutiny targets high-income individuals with minimal bank withdrawals, hinting at potential cash transactions that are not reported. “Notices are being issued demanding a detailed breakdown of monthly expenses, including groceries, dining, clothing, and education. For instance, if a taxpayer reports an annual income of Rs 50 lakh but withdraws only Rs 10,000 per month, it raises concerns about unreported income. With AI-driven analysis and digital payment tracking, discrepancies between declared income and actual spending are more evident than ever. This shift underscores the importance of accurate financial disclosures to avoid unwanted scrutiny,” Shah explains.
Also Read: Supreme Court: Court Judgments Are Retrospective Unless Specified Otherwise
Why Are Taxpayers Required to Provide Detailed Expense Breakdowns?
If an individual’s lifestyle and spending habits appear to exceed what is accounted for by their financial records, they may be asked to submit a detailed breakdown of their expenditures. The purpose of this request is to verify the source of funds and detect any unreported income, particularly in cash transactions. A significant gap between reported expenses and traceable financial transactions may indicate undisclosed income, which is subject to taxation.
The Income Tax Department may seek information on major expenditures such as:
- Medical bills
- Foreign travel expenses
- Lifestyle costs (dining, entertainment, luxury shopping)
- Household expenses (groceries, utilities, salaries)
- Investments (real estate, stocks, gold, and jewelry)
While some experts believe this level of scrutiny is necessary for transparency, others argue that excessive details on personal spending could be seen as an invasion of privacy.
Legal Basis: Section 142(1) of the Income Tax Act
Under Section 142(1) of the Income Tax Act, assessing officers can request detailed information on various household expenses, including groceries, utilities, clothing, personal care, entertainment, education, transportation, insurance, housing, and other miscellaneous costs.
Ritika Nayyar, Partner at Singhania & Co., states, “If expenses appear significantly higher than what can be justified by documented income sources, individuals may be required to provide detailed breakdowns. The objective is to ensure that all income, especially cash earnings, is reported for tax purposes. Any discrepancies between declared spending and traceable financial activity can trigger inquiries.”
How Common Is Such Scrutiny?
According to government data, only 1% of all income tax returns undergo an extensive review. In the fiscal year ending March 2024, out of 72.8 million tax filers, only a small percentage received detailed notices requesting expenditure breakdowns. Such inquiries are usually triggered when a taxpayer’s lifestyle and financial transactions do not align with their reported income.
A government official told CNBC TV18, “The tax department is focusing on individuals who maintain a high standard of living despite minimal documented withdrawals. Random scrutiny cases have revealed instances where recorded withdrawals are insufficient to cover even basic living expenses. This raises suspicion of unaccounted income. By asking for detailed expenditure information, assessing officers aim to uncover undeclared cash transactions.”
Final Thoughts
As tax compliance regulations tighten, individuals must maintain accurate records of their earnings and expenses to avoid scrutiny. The use of AI and digital tracking tools has made it easier for authorities to detect discrepancies in financial reporting. To ensure smooth tax filing and prevent unnecessary inquiries, taxpayers should adopt transparent financial practices and report all sources of income correctly.
For those receiving such notices, seeking professional advice from tax consultants can help navigate the process effectively and avoid potential penalties.
READ MORE