ITAT clarifies that a builder’s mistake in flat allotment will not hinder a taxpayer’s ability to claim tax benefits under section 54 of the I-T Act.
In a recent case adjudicated by the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), Mumbai bench, a taxpayer named Mukesh Harilal Mehta successfully claimed a tax deduction under section 54 of the Income-tax (I-T) Act for the financial year 2014-15. The ITAT ruled that despite an error made by the builder in allocating the flat, Mehta’s claim for tax benefits cannot be denied.
The builder had mistakenly assigned the flat purchased by Mehta to another buyer. However, upon acknowledging the mistake, the builder provided Mehta with a similarly situated flat within the same building. Section 54 of the I-T Act allows for an exemption on long-term capital gains arising from the sale of a residential property if the gains are reinvested in the purchase of another residential property within a specific timeframe.
Mehta fulfilled all the necessary conditions under this section. Yet, during the assessment, the I-T officer initially rejected the claim due to the absence of a registered sale deed to prove the purchase of the new flat. Additionally, there were differences noted between the details of the new flat mentioned in the possession letter and the originally allocated flat.
The ITAT deemed the denial of the exemption unjustified, citing that Mehta should not be penalized for the builder’s error in flat allocation. This ruling of ITAT offers clarity to taxpayers facing similar situations where builders make errors in property allocation.
Understanding Section 54 of the Income-tax Act
Section 54 of the Income-tax Act permits individuals to claim tax exemption on long-term capital gains from the sale of residential property. This exemption is applicable if the proceeds are reinvested in the purchase of a new residential property. The new property must be acquired within one year prior to the sale or within two years post the sale. Alternatively, the capital gain can be invested in the construction of a new residential property within three years from the original property’s sale. This provision aims to encourage individuals to reinvest their gains from property sales into residential real estate, thereby stimulating growth in the real estate sector.
Implications for Taxpayers
The recent ITAT ruling establishes a precedent that a builder’s mistake in flat allotment will not hinder a taxpayer’s ability to claim tax benefits under section 54 of the I-T Act. This news is particularly reassuring for individuals encountering similar challenges with property developers. The decision ensures that taxpayers are not held accountable for mistakes beyond their control and protects their right to avail tax deductions in accordance with the law.
Taxpayers who find themselves in situations where a builder has incorrectly allocated a purchased flat should now feel confident in claiming the necessary tax benefits. It is crucial for such individuals to gather evidence of the transaction, including payment receipts, possession letters, and correspondence with the builder, to support their claim for tax exemption. Adequate documentation plays a pivotal role in establishing the connection between the sale of the old property and the purchase of a new one.
Conclusion
The ITAT’s ruling provides relief to taxpayers, assuring them that a builder’s error in flat allocation will not impede their ability to claim tax benefits under section 54 of the I-T Act. This decision upholds taxpayers’ rights and ensures fair treatment, even in scenarios where challenges arise due to builders’ mistakes.
Moving forward, individuals facing similar instances of property misallocation should compile all relevant documentation and present it to tax authorities to assert their right to claim appropriate tax benefits. This ruling underscores the principle that taxpayers should not bear undue consequences for errors made by others, emphasizing the necessity of clear guidelines in the tax benefit claim process.
Also Read: Delhi High Court Dismisses Congress Party Plea Against Income Tax Re-Assessment for 2014-17
Read More
CBDT Notification 33/2024: Lower Tax Rates on Royalties & FTS in India-Spain Tax Agreement
CBDT Notification 34/2024: Corrigendum to Notification 27/2024 Dated 5 March 2024